Free Tools · Menu Engineering Calculator

Menu engineering calculator: find your stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs.

Enter what each dish sells and what it costs to plate. The calculator sorts your menu by popularity and profit, shows your real food cost, and tells you which items to promote, reprice, reposition or cut.

Free calculator

Your menu items

Use one category at a time (for example, entrées only) for the most accurate result. Pull units sold from your POS for the same period, such as the last 30 days. The sample items below are placeholders; replace them with your own.

Menu itemUnits soldMenu price ($)Plate cost ($)
Your results
Total revenue–
Food cost %–
Total contribution margin–
Avg margin per dish–
ItemClassMenu mixMargin / dishFood costWhat to do

Uses the standard Kasavana–Smith method: an item is popular if its share of sales is at least 70% of an even share, and profitable if its margin per dish is at or above the sales-weighted average. Estimates only; prices, waste and labor also matter.

The short answer

How does menu engineering work?

Every dish gets two scores: popularity (its share of units sold) and profit (its contribution margin, which is price minus plate cost).

A dish is popular if it sells at least 70% of what an even share would be. With 10 items, an even share is 10% of sales, so anything at 7% or more counts as popular. A dish is profitable if its margin per plate is at or above your menu’s weighted average. Those two yes-or-no answers place it in one of four groups.

The four groups

What to do with each dish

Star

Popular and profitable

Protect these. Keep quality and portions consistent, give them the best spot on the menu, and make them the dishes in your photos and ads.

Plowhorse

Popular, lower margin

Guests love them, but they earn less. Raise the price a little, re-cost the plate, trim an expensive garnish, or pair them with a high-margin side or drink.

Puzzle

Profitable, slow seller

Great margin, not enough orders. Rename them, move them to a better spot on the menu, have servers recommend them, and test them in ads and social posts.

Dog

Slow seller, lower margin

Cut, rework or replace them, unless one has a loyal following or is a key part of the menu. Fewer dogs usually means less waste and simpler prep.

From the menu to your marketing

Put your ad money behind stars and puzzles.

The dishes you photograph, post and advertise should be the ones that make you money. We use this analysis before every restaurant campaign we run.

Stars go into Google Business Profile photos, Meta ads and email headers. Puzzles get tested in ads and on the menu to see if more people will order them. Plowhorses can drive traffic as a hook, but price them so each one still earns a margin. Running ads behind a dog just pays to sell more of a dish that loses you money.

See our restaurant marketing →

FAQ

Menu engineering questions

What is menu engineering?

Menu engineering is a way of scoring every dish on two things: how often it sells (popularity) and how much money it leaves after food cost (contribution margin). Each dish lands in one of four groups (stars, plowhorses, puzzles or dogs), and each group gets a different action.

How do I calculate contribution margin for a dish?

Contribution margin is the menu price minus the plate cost. A $24 dish that costs $7 to plate has a $17 contribution margin. Use your recipe cost for the plate, including garnish, sides and sauces.

What is a good food cost percentage for a restaurant?

Many full-service restaurants aim for roughly 28 to 35 percent food cost, but the right number depends on your concept and prices. A steakhouse runs higher than a pizzeria. Margin dollars per dish matter more than the percentage alone.

How often should I run menu engineering?

Run it each time you change the menu, and at least every quarter. Seasonal items and price changes on ingredients can move a dish from star to plowhorse quickly.

Should I advertise my best-selling dishes?

Advertise stars first, since they sell well and make money. Puzzles (high margin, low sales) are the next best candidates, because better photos, menu placement and ads can lift their sales. Avoid putting ad money behind dogs.

Free restaurant audit

Want us to run this on your menu?

Send us your POS menu-mix report and we’ll show you which dishes to push, reprice or cut, and how to put them in front of the right guests.