Restaurants

Toast email marketing: how restaurants use it to bring guests back.

If you run on Toast, you already collect guest emails with every online order and many in-house checks. Here is how to turn that list into repeat visits, and how to measure which emails actually bring people back.

Key takeaways

  • Toast Email Marketing sends targeted promotions using guest and ordering data from Toast POS and Toast Online Ordering, so there is no list to export.
  • Set up the automated campaigns first: welcome, birthday, win-back and slow-day offers.
  • Segment by behavior: regulars, lapsed guests, online-order guests and big spenders get different messages.
  • Measure orders and revenue after each send, and compare offers against a holdout group when you can.

What is Toast Email Marketing?

Toast Email Marketing is Toast’s built-in email tool for restaurants. It sends targeted promotions using guest and ordering data from Toast POS and Toast Online Ordering, so your guest list builds itself as people order.

It sits inside Toast Marketing, which also covers SMS, so email and text can run from the same guest data. Because it is connected to the POS, you can see which campaigns lead to orders instead of guessing. Source: Toast.

Why does email matter so much for restaurants?

Because a small group of regulars drives a large share of sales. Toast and Resy’s Regulars Report found that at a cohort of restaurants, the 7% of guests who return more than once can generate up to half of total order volume.

Email is the cheapest way to stay in front of those guests. Toast also reports that most orders driven by its email and SMS campaigns come from guests who had already dined at the restaurant, which is exactly who these campaigns should target. Source: Toast.

Which Toast email campaigns should a restaurant set up first?

Start with four automated campaigns that run in the background, then add one or two timed sends a month.

CampaignWho gets itWhat it says
WelcomeNew guests from online orders or sign-upsThanks, your story, one reason to come back soon
BirthdayGuests with a birthday on fileA birthday treat that brings a group in
Win-backGuests who have not ordered in 45 to 60 daysA reason to return: new dish, offer or event
Slow-day offerRegulars within driving distanceAn offer for your slowest day or daypart

Timed sends cover new menus, seasonal dishes, events, catering and holiday ordering. Keep each email to one message and one button.

How should you segment Toast guest data?

  • Regulars: frequent guests get early access and recognition, not discounts they would not need.
  • Lapsed guests: people who used to come regularly and stopped get your strongest offer.
  • Online ordering guests: promote pickup windows, family meals and catering.
  • High spenders: invite them to tasting menus, private events and wine dinners.
  • Birthdays and anniversaries: a simple, well-timed treat.

How do you measure Toast email results?

Measure orders and revenue in the days after each send, not opens. Toast shows campaign performance alongside sales, and offer codes or unique menu items make redemptions easy to count.

When the list is large enough, hold back a small group that does not get the email and compare their orders with the group that did. That shows what the email actually added, not what would have happened anyway.

How does Black X use Cheeky Merlin with Toast email?

Cheeky Merlin, the predictive platform our team built, scores which guest segments are most likely to respond to which offer, forecasts orders and revenue before a send, then compares the forecast with Toast data afterward.

We pair email with SMS for time-sensitive offers, local SEO so new guests find you, and paid ads that grow the list in the first place. We do not run your social media accounts or design graphics; you supply the photos and we build campaigns that are tracked to orders.

What are common Toast email mistakes?

  • Sending the same discount to every guest, including regulars who would have come anyway.
  • Only emailing when business is slow, so guests learn to wait for a deal.
  • Long newsletters with five messages and no single action.
  • Never checking orders after a send, so bad campaigns keep running.
  • Ignoring SMS for time-sensitive offers that email is too slow for.
Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is Toast Email Marketing included with Toast POS?

Toast sells email marketing as part of its marketing products, and pricing depends on your plan. Check your Toast plan or ask your Toast representative which marketing features you have.

How often should a restaurant send emails?

Automated welcome, birthday and win-back emails run on their own. On top of that, two to four timed emails a month is a good starting point. Watch unsubscribes and orders after each send and adjust.

Can Toast send SMS as well as email?

Yes. Toast Marketing includes SMS alongside email, using the same guest data. Text works best for short, time-sensitive offers; email for menus, events and stories.

Can you manage Toast email marketing for us?

Yes. Black X sets up the campaigns and segments, writes the emails using your photos, forecasts results with Cheeky Merlin and reports orders and revenue from each send.

Free projection

See the number before you spend.

Tell us your budget and customer value. We will send a written projection of what your advertising should produce, free.